Saturday, June 17, 2006

In Memory of Makana Na Ota E 'En

Here's a marker marker near an old haunt of mine; Terrace Park Swimming Pool and Covell Lake.

In Memory of Makana Na Ota E 'En
Ennraged over the broken promises of the white man, the Santee Sioux, led by Chief Little Crow, launched the "War of the Outbreak" - or "Dakota War" -- in August, 1882, along the Minnesota River. Little Crow ordered White Lodge's band, camped near Lake Benton, Minnesota, to drive out the settlers along the Dakota border and in the Big Sioux River valley.
On August 25, 1862, Judge Joseph B. Amidon and his son, William, were slain by Indians while making hay near the north edge of Sioux Falls. Territorial Governor William Jayne ordered evacuation of the settlement. Following the Yankton Stage Trail, the settlers fled to Yankton, led by a detachment of Dakota Cavalry.
In November, a scouting party under Captain Nelson Miner returned to Sioux Falls. Included in the party were a number of civilians who had been residents of Sioux Falls before its evacuation. Many of the civilians had chached goods which they how wished to recover. Using caution, the scouting party camped overnight on the south side of the Big Sioux River near the present location of the Yankton Trail Bridge. They continued at dawn and when "they reached the top of the south hills" (present day 14th Street between Dakota and Minnesota Avenues) they not only discovered the settlement burned and in ruin, but also sighted a band of Indians near the Falls.

On signal, the cavalry charged. The Indians scattered to the north and west and escaped, save one man, who missed the unmarked trail crossing Covell's Slough and whose horse floundered in the mud near this spot. Soldiers fired and wounded him. Injured and on foot, he was killed by a mounted soldier's saber slashes. The cavalry reported the slain man to be Wa-keyan-doota, a nephew of the notorious renegade, Inkpaduta.
The Indian killed was not Inkpaduta's nephew. He was Makana Na Ota E 'En, which could be translated to Among Many Little Trees. He was a member of the visiting band who had no part in the Amidon murders or the sack of Sioux Falls. His only crime was being an Indian. Later his companions returned and buried him near the top of a nearby high point.
Years later, in 1931, his true identity was related by his sister, Rattling Wings Woman. For some time, she unsuccessfully sought the burial place of her slain brother. It is thought that the unmarked grave of Makana Na Ota E 'En is in upper Terrace Park.
Makana Na Ota E 'En, like the Amidons, was a tragic casualty in the eddies of violence surrounding the Dakota War.
Erected in 1993 by the Minnehaha County and South Dakota
Historical Societies, the Minnehaha Century Fund and
the Mary Chilton DAR Foundation

Wow. The policy of "shoot first, ask questions later" really sucks. I wonder how different things would be in this area — this country — if we had taken the time to not only talk but communicate, and live up to our agreements.
It's probably a good thing that this marker wasn't put up until 1993, otherwise I, along with every other North-End kid, would've been digging holes all over Terrace Park looking for this guy's bones.
And yet another reference to the Amidon murders. Was it the fact that Joseph Amidon was a judge that caused people to react the way they did? Or maybe it was the way Joseph and William were killed; from movies and TV we get the impression that that sort of Indian-on-white attack was common. Perhaps it wasn't at all common, and the fact that the Amidons were attacked without provocation caused the people of Sioux Falls to strike back in this way.

West Sioux Falls

Here's a marker found near the Elmwood Park ball diamonds in northwest Sioux Falls (Google Maps link.)

West Sioux Falls
In March 1889, several months before South Dakota achieved statehood, Evan B. Meredith, first president of the University of Sioux Falls, platted a future residential community within the northwest boundary of early Sioux Falls. His purpose was to raise funds through land sales for the struggling school. The area quickly became known as West Sioux Falls.
The intersection of present day Burnside and Madison Streets and Lincoln Avenue was its focal point. Prior to 1900, the growing community included several modest homes and farm buildings, Beuhlah Baptist Church, Meredith School, Edson Grocery and wooded Meredith Park. The earliest residents hauled water from a small shallow well next to the grocery store which was soon replaced by a larger community well located at the northwest corner of Bailey Street and Garfield Avenue. Industrial and agricultural businesses were established west of the Big Sioux River. Despite the economic hard times which followed the Panic of 1893 and which existed into the new century, the community continued to grow.
Following World War I, the surrounding flat grassy fields served as makeshift landing sites for barnstorming aviators. Thrilling air shows included stunt flying, wing-walking, parachute jumps, and aerial acrobatics. In 1920 a 40 acre West Soo Amusement Park was opened in the former Meredith Park. The up-and-coming Lawrence Welk Orchestra and other musical groups regularly played for public dances held in the dance pavilion.

A spectacular display of fireworks each Fourth of July, ball diamonds and regularly scheduled semi-pro baseball games, a shaded picnic area and fishing and swimming in the Big Sioux River drew large crowds to the park. Scenic Elmwood Park was established in 1924. It extended north of the residential community and is now an integral part of the 18-hole Elmwood Municipal Golf Course.
For many years, an impressive collection of mounted wild animals was displayed at West Sioux Hardware. The trophies were collected by Henry Brockhouse, a long-time community businessman and resident and an avid sportsman. His safari hunting expeditions covered a period of 35 years and spanned four continents. Generally regarded as the largest private collection in the world, it was sold in 1985 and became a major attraction at the Delbridge Museum of Natural History at the Sioux Falls Great Plains Zoo.
Beuhlah Baptist Church, more than a century old, together with several early homes, and the florist greenhouse remain at their original locations. The quartzite stone quarrying business has vastly expanded. This varied arrangement of business, cultural, and recreational undertakings circling residential West Sioux Falls confirms the unique importance of this area which has flourished for over 100 years.
Dedicated in 1996 by the
Minnehaha County and South Dakota State Historical Societies,
University of Sioux Falls, the Amby & Viola Westendorf Family, Dust-Tex Services, Inc., Descendants of Henry W. Smith Family, and the Feay Family.

I remember going to West Sioux Hardware as a kid, and marvelling at the animals on display there. There seemed to be an endless string of rooms filled with the trophies; enough to keep a kid more than busy for however long it'd take for Dad to take care of business up front.
Other than the old hardware store, and the fact that I was once employed near the West Sioux area, I don't feel much of a connection with the area. Mom & Dad would talk about the days of going to the West Sioux Pavilion (I think that's what it was called) for dances and whatnot, but these days it's just another neighborhood. But I guess every neighborhood has some history behind it.

The Old Yankton Trail and Stage Road

Here is preserved a section of

Over this trail the people
of Sioux Falls fled to Yankton
under cavalry escort for
safety from hostile
Sioux indians, Aug. 28, 1862.
This tablet placed by Sophomore
Class of 1926 Sioux Falls College.
Minnehaha County Historical Society

This is the oldest marker I've yet seen, placed in 1926. The second photo doesn't really give a good sense of what is there; the remnants of the ruts left behind by wagon wheels and horse traffic. The site is located on the campus of The University of Sioux Falls (formerly Sioux Falls College.) I'm not aware of any other undisturbed sections of the old trail, but there is a street named Old Yankton Trail Road that presumably follows the original. I would imagine that there are other sections of the original in more remote regions that have survived.

Amidon Graves Mystery

Here is another marker about the death of the Amidons and the mystery of their final resting place. This marker is within sight of the grand Pioneer Memorial monument (Google Maps link.)

Amidon Graves Mystery
About 200 yards southwest of this marker is the location long supposed by historians to be the burial site of Judge Joseph Amidon and his son William, ambushed and killed by Santee Sioux warriors on August 25, 1862. The Sioux war party was under orders to clear all settlers from the Big Sioux River valley.
For decades the belief was held by many that the Amidons had been interred near where they fell. A linear earthen mound, about 30 feet long, eight feet wide, and four feet high, strewn with rocks and large boulders, was understood to mark their gravesites.

In 1991 the Augustana College Archeology Lab was employed to excavate the presumed burial mound. A crew led by archeologists Dr. L. Adrien Hannus and Peter Winham methodically extracted nine soil core samples, dug four one-meter square excavations, and cut a 21-foot long backhoe trench. No evidence of human interments was found; only debris piled up by farmers for almost a century was uncovered. The location of the Amidon graves remains a mystery.

Dedicated in 2001 by the Minnehaha County Historical Society and the Sioux Falls Development Foundation, Inc.

It seems a bit strange to me that the digging referred to here took place at all when there was a first-hand account from one of the Cavalry soldiers that the bodies were buried "... in a cemetery ...(on what is now)... North Duluth Avenue." I guess this is a case where local legend overrides what is known through written documents.

But you know, I grew up in the area near North Duluth Avenue, and I don't recall ever seeing a cemetery there. I wonder what happened to that place. Hmmm.

Friday, June 16, 2006

The Pioneer Memorial, and The Amidon Affair

This marker is probably one of the grandest in the city, because of its location and because of the monument at the same site. First the story, as told by the markers at the site.

The Amidon Affair

The 1862 Sioux Uprising, a result of unjust government treatment, claimed many Indian and non-Indian lives. Near this place on August 25, 1862, two of its victims, Judge Joseph B. Amidon and his son, William, were killed while making hay on their claim which was a mile north of their cabin in Sioux Falls.

Amidon was a County Probate Judge, Treasurer and Commisioner appointed by Governor Jayne and the Territorial Legislature. When he and William failed to return home at sundown, Mrs. Amidon became alarmed and sought help from the Dakota Calvalry (sic) detachment in the village. A search was to no avail, but the bodies were found in the morning. Joseph died of a single bullet wound. William was riddled with arrows.

George B. Trumbo brought their bodies back to the village. Later, Sg. Jesse Buel Watson, Company A, Dakota Cavalry, reported, "We picked up the bodies and buried them in a cemetery ...(on what is now)... North Duluth Avenue."

In the opinion of John Renville and Joseph Laframboise, veteran fur traders and plainsmen, the Amidons were slain by members of the band of the warrior White Lodge. He was under orders from Chief Little Crow, Indian leader in the "Dakota Ware", to drive white settlers from the Sioux Valley. Pure chance placed the Amidons in the path of White Lodge's scouting party.

Two days later, orders came by courier from Governor William Jayne to abandon Sioux Falls and seek shelter at the Territorial Capitol at Yankton. Settlers and soldiers together hastily set out in a wagon train before sundown.

Following the settlers' flight to Yankton, Sioux Falls remained abandoned until the establishment of Fort Dakota by federal troops in 1865, when settlement was resumed.

Joseph B. Amidon was born in Connecticut in 1801. He came to Sioux Falls from Saint Paul, Minnesota, with his wife Mahala, son William and daughter Eliza, sometime before 1860.

Erected in 1991 by the Minnehaha County Historical Society, the South Dakota State Historical Society and the South Dakota Department of Transportation.

The marker is located on the edge of a bluff overlooking the Big Sioux River (Google Maps satellite view). I don't know why the Amidon's chose this spot for their hay field, but if it were me settling the area back in 1860, I certainly would've built my home there, just for the view. Unfortunately, time and the development of Sioux Falls has not been kind to this spot, for just down the hill to the south is the waste water treatment plant retention ponds and the John Morrell meat packing plant. To the east is Barney's Auto Salvage, an eyesore from the ground and the air. And just around the bend to the west is the South Dakota State Penitentiary. If not for those four facilities, this area would be the most desirable residential property in eastern South Dakota.

I've long wondered what it was about the deaths of the Amidons that made the event worthy of monuments like this, because there were many early settlers who died either at the hands of Indians or any number of other causes. But in reading the story, the event was apparently the catalyst which led to the evacuation and the 3-year abandonment of the Sioux Falls settlement. That was a major event in the history of the city.

The bronze marker is accompanied on the site by a huge granite obelisk that was erected in 1949. A plaque on the monument reads as follows:

1856 -- 1889


Another marker, made of engraved granite is mounted at the base of the obelisk, and reads...

The Pioneer Memorial
Honors the early settlers who faced the harsh and lonely prairie, the ferocity of the elements, and the uncertainty of their fate in this new land between 1856 when Sioux Falls city was platted and 1889 when South Dakota achieved statehood. They built homes, farms and businesses and planted their family roots in Minnehaha county. This Sioux Quartzite obelisk was erected in their memory in 1949.
Minnehaha County Historical Society

Seems odd that the MCHS would see the need to expand on the original plaque on the obelisk. I sometimes fancy the idea of being a settler in this area back in the mid-1800's, but I don't know if I would've fared very well. Those that did were made of tougher stuff, and they deserve our admiration.